The Toronto Maple Leafs wrapped up a frustrating and fruitless six-game homestand this weekend with a loss to the Edmonton Oilers – the worst string of regulation losses in a homestand not just in the franchise’s 110-year history, but tied for the worst in the history of the league, matching just the 1971/72 Los Angeles Kings.
So needless to say, things are tense in town. A lot more tense than, say, the excitement when Toronto rolled through the Oilers 7-2 in their last matchup against each other three Saturdays prior, or the “this team is different” energy when fans saw the Leafs bench react to Troy Stecher’s last-minute game winner two days prior to that.
Facing the most of the energy right now is Jim Hiller, who might have had the quickest fanbase-souring in recent Leafs memory – at least since Peter Horachek’s interim run off the cliff back in 2014/15. Calls for the Head Coach’s job started as fodder for social media and message boards earlier last week and have started to leak their way onto blogs and written media, into TV and radio segments, and into even questions about Hiller’s job security in a media availability done by General Manager John Chayka.
It’s all a little wild to see this fast. While most of it lands on vague “this isn’t good enough, so change something” routines, some of it is especially nonsensical.
One video going around shows a popular Leafs content creator implying, from a “friend of a player”, that Hiller has completely lost the Leafs dressing room, particularly forward William Nylander. This makes for great consumption fodder for a fan that’s already upset about the team’s play, but after a half-beat of thought, should settle in as nonsensical. The same group that everyone felt looked tighter-knit than every three weeks ago is now in disarray? Hiller, hired in part because of character endorsements from the long-term core players who had him as an assistant, has managed to lose a room in 22 games and has particularly burned the most nonchalant of that core group? The same William Nylander who mozied through two years of Craig Berube coaching the exact opposite of playstyle to his own for two years without an outwardly shown care in the world?
Another article I read today described the team as looking “far worse than they ever did last year under Berube”, comparing them negatively to a team that finished dead last in Corsi differential for the first time since the Randy Carlyle era, got outshot 62 times in 82 games, and played absolutely painful to watch hockey. The Leafs still have a lot of work to do to get back in the green from a perspective of controlling play, but have made improvements by nearly every team skater metric this year and, on most nights, have been significantly more entertaining. Even in the homestand from hell, Toronto managed to out-attempt a roster of very good opponents 295-281 at 5-on-5. Score effects (pressing a protecting team while trailing) are no doubt a factor there, but they’ve been a team that’s lost games that they’re hanging around, rather than one that’s been getting their lunch fed.
Toronto’s shooting percentage (5.7) sits dead last in the league in November and their save percentage (0.865) sits 25th. For reference, that shooting percentage is over a full point lower than the worst full-season mark recorded in the past 66 years, so that’s probably not something you can expect to keep up.
None of this absolves a losing streak – Chayka called the recent homestand “unacceptable” in his availability, and for any team trying to win hockey games, it should be, but it does indicate that the group probably hasn’t irredeemably fallen apart, nor would they be likely to repeat particularly often it if you ran that homestand back a bunch of times over. Once you reach that conclusion, how eager should you be to fire a coach a quarter of a season into his tenure?
Hiller wasn’t my first choice for the Maple Leafs’ head coaching gig. Without being able to interview anyone myself, I was more intrigued by names like Bruce Cassidy (no-nonsense and demanding of work, but also someone who likes his team to have the puck), Jay Woodcroft (ran some very up-tempo and fun Oilers teams despite deficiencies in the back end) or Todd Nelson (only one year in the NHL big chair, but immense success at the AHL level). I also don’t agree with every decision he makes. I was confused as everyone was when he glued Gavin McKenna to the bench against Buffalo, though I’m not as enamoured with his 5-on-5 deployment since then as most people are (if we’re being honest, he’s not been great at even strength). I’d prefer to play McKenna more on the powerplay than Toronto has, I’d prefer to play Sergei Bobrovsky less in any situation, and every time the Leafs have tried to go in to a shell to protect a lead, I’ve cringed (though as the losing streak has shown, better to brace than to chase, I suppose).
I’m also trying to be realistic about things here. For starters, I’m generally of the belief that coaching staffs are like goaltenders. There are only a few head coaches that matter, and if you don’t have one of those, you should basically just avoid an obvious grenade and get somebody okay and personable. Whether there’s a Coach That Matters (TM) available to the Leafs is up for you to decide, but I think Hiller is at least within the tier of the acceptable fallback, especially if he’s willing to adapt as the team goes.
There’s also the matter of understanding the bosses we’re dealing with here. A lot of the talk about the hiring of Hiller and Chayka and the general slimming down of the team’s front office and staff, is that the organization, as much as they talk a big talk, aren’t as willing to spend on manpower as they used to be. What used to be the easiest area for them to flex has now become an area of “if we can’t re-sell it as an asset later, we don’t want to spend on it”, a degree of hesitance we already began to see within MLSE after the early firing of Mike Babcock but one that’s only gotten more obvious since. All this to say, with Berube still being paid out, do we believe the team would add a second coach to pay to not work without their backs being to the absolute wall? If they were to do so, would it be a top candidate at all costs, or would the team end up in another bang-for-buck scenario?
If it turns out that being one of the worst finishing and puck-stopping teams of our lifetime is permanent, then sure, he’ll eventually be let go. But even that move likely leads to an interim solution for the remainder of the year, as Rogers definitely won’t want to risk whiffing yet again on another snap candidate. Do the Leafs do better if John Gruden, one of Hiller’s best friends and a frequent co-worker, slides up to a different chair? Or if they hand the keys to Daniel Alfredsson, who outside of the fever dream of him being on the bench in the first place, has never been a head coach at any competitive level?
Realistically, much of this begins to balance itself out in the coming days and weeks. The current skaters stat to find the back of the net more, and they get back an elite forward in Kirill Marchenko from injury to add a missing layer of dynamicism (Toronto is 1-7 in his absence, 1-8 if you include the game he was injured in). You get some help on the blue line when Morgan Rielly gets back (imagine saying that to a critic last year), and you start getting more saves as either Sergei Bobrovsky figures some of his issues out or defers more starts to Anthony Stolarz. They string together a few wins, everyone calms down for a bit, and they continue building towards whatever they are. For me, that’s still a team in and around the wildcard mix, though right now it’s looking more “around” than “in” if they don’t start stacking some wins back soon. People still wonder if there’s someone better out there for them, but the “lost room” murmurs fade and people stop wishing for teams that were worse to watch and hand worse net results because they’re frustrated with seeing L6 on the standings.
Ultimately, my point here isn’t to dismiss feelings of frustration or to absolve Hiller and the rest of the staff from criticism. Watching your favourite team lose hurts, and I think that voicing concerns about potential adjustments isn’t just acceptable but necessary, if done thoughtfully. The Leafs still remain a far-from-polished product, and part of that comes from the bench. But it can also be recognized that this was a particularly unfortunate couple of weeks, and that even if this was completely a product of ineptitude, the odds of a fruitful parachute plan at this time of year with this organization aren’t exactly high.
In other words, hope for some good bounces, push for good adjustments, but collectively, biting off more than can be chewed right now is more dramatic than it is helpful.
