It’s official! Wait, maybe drop the exclamation point. The Toronto Maple Leafs just had the worst homestand in NHL history, matching the 1971/72 Los Angeles Kings as the only teams to ever host six home games in a row and come out pointless, capping off the run with a 1-0 loss to the Edmonton Oilers.
The Rundown
This game was a stingy one, featuring just 42 total shots on goal, and depending on who you ask, one or two goals.
The goal we can all agree on was the one that counted, which came with about five minutes left in the second period. It was Edmonton’s tally, and you don’t have to ask who factored in on it. While Easton Cowan almost cut off a Leon Draisaitl pass, his break up knocked the puck straight to Connor McDavid, who found Evan Bouchard up high, and the high-scoring blue liner blasted a slapshot past a screen of Vasily Podkolzin and Jake McCabe, leaving an otherwise-perfect Anthony Stolarz unable to see what had come his way.
A minute into the third period, we got the goal that fewer could agree on. William Nylander ripped a wrist shot from distance that was deflected by John Tavares. The officials on the ice initially ruled it a goal, but after several minutes of reviewing the footage, declared the puck to be conclusively hit by a high stick and disallowed the tally. From here, Toronto just didn’t generate enough to get themselves back into the game. They made their usual last-minute push, including a goalie-like save by Auston Matthews as Connor McDavid attempted to score on an empty Toronto net, and between-the-legs shot by Matthews that almost tied the game in the final seconds, but none of it was enough to snap Devon Levi’s shutout.
Notes
- Gotta feel bad for Anthony Stolarz. Finally gets his first consecutive pair of starts this year, looks absolutely stellar, and the team can’t even get him a goal.
- As criticism towards Jim Hiller seeps into the mainstream media, one talking point I saw come from a couple notable names was that it was a bad idea for the Leafs to have put the fourth line up against Edmonton’s first. I don’t understand this at all. Not only were the fourth line only matched up against the McDavid line for a quarter of his minutes, but they also kept him to zero goals. Shutting down the literal best line in the world to free up time for everyone else seems pretty good, and probably not the place where I’d put blame.
- One area that would be a bit more valid is the top powerplay unit, which finished the homestand 2 for 14, including 1 for 10 in the last four games. Many will point to the removal of Gavin McKenna from the unit as part of the problem, which I think is fair. I think he was a big help to that top unit in his time on it. Where I diverge is on whether or not the solution is to remove John Tavares again, as many have put the blame on appeasing him. I’d instead consider swapping out Jack Roslovic, who has been great at 5-on-5 but has generated little in terms of both production and shot generation. You lose a little in transition, but McKenna should be able to handle the odd carry-in and will be better at finding seams once you’re set up.
- That non-goal is an incredibly frustrating call. None of the angles shown on the broadcast, at the very least, had any reason to believe you could conclusively tell whether Tavares’ stick was high or not. The fact it took the situation room five minutes to review leads one to believe that there wasn’t a secret tell-all angle available just to them either. Had the officials ruled no-goal from the start, I wouldn’t have blinked at their conclusion, but I think calling it a goal and overturning it is an awful look here.
- On a shot control basis, this was one of the best games in a while for the Tavares and Nylander. The second line broke even on shot attempts and took their attempts from better areas, leading to an 82% share of expected goals. That’s especially promising given that they mostly faced the second line. Only two of those attempts being shots on goal probably is less helpful, though – not bleeding is great, but winning an absence-of-hockey tradeoff isn’t significantly better.
- I really don’t think the Leafs were “worst team to ever do this” bad on this homestand. But six regulation losses in a row in front of the home crowd is still unacceptable, and “we were right there on a few of them” excuses, even if valid in the micro, aren’t going to fly in the big picture. They need to shake this off fast – it’s getting late early.
- Lots of attention of this nationally broadcasted Leafs game, John Tavares controversially has a tying goal taken away from him – what do you mean Nick Paul didn’t have a goal in him this time?
Up Next
Finally, another crowd gets to watch this team while they sort themselves out. The Leafs head to Chicago to take on the Blackhawks on Tuesday night. Can facing a minnow in a new environment be the shakeup they need? We’ll find out when they drop the puck at 7:30 PM.
Numbers Game
| Top Performers | Bottom Performers | Top Opponents |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Chris Tanev (1.82) 0G, 0A, 0 SOG, 82% xG | 1. Gavin McKenna (-0.91) 0G, 0A, 0 SOG, 48% xG | 1. Connor McDavid (2.46) 0G, 1A, 0 SOG, +1, 49% xG |
| 2. Oliver Ekman-Larsson (1.37) 0G, 0A, 2 SOG, 72% xG | 2. Dakota Joshua (-0.59) 0G, 0A, 0 SOG, 49% xG | 2. Devon Levi (2.19) 19 saves, 0 GA on 2.19 xGA |
| 3. John Tavares (1.07) 0G, 0A, 2 SOG, 80% xG | 3. Nick Paul (-0.57) 0G, 0A, 2 SOG, 51% xG | 3. Leon Draisaitl (2.00) 0G, 1A, 4 SOG, +1, 47% xG |

| Shots On Goal | 23-19 EDM | Faceoffs | 24 for 48 |
| 5v5 Shot Attempts | 49-39 EDM | Hits | 30-24 TOR |
| 5v5 Expected Goals | 1.95-1.82 TOR | Blocked Shots | 22-16 TOR |
| Best Period (xG) | 5v5: 3rd (55%) All: 1st (52%) | Powerplay | 0 for 1 (1 shot) |
| Worst Period (xG) | 5v5: 2nd (50%) All: 3rd (23%) | Penalty Kill | 1 for 1 (2 shots) |
Table 1: Game Score via Dom, HockeyStatCards recommended for full-game results
Table 2: Derived from NHL.com and Natural Stat Trick
Heatmap: via Natural Stat Trick
